# Chabad Torah Trop — Research Report for a Lein-Practice Tool

**Date:** 2026-11-17 · **Scope:** Torah only, Chabad (Lubavitch) tradition · **Research only — no building.**

## 0. Bottom line

- There is **no published, note-for-note "Chabad trop" chart** that I could find anywhere. The Chabad melody is documented in **recordings**, not in staff notation.
- The closest thing to a reproducible text source is **TropeTrainer (tropetrainer.com)**, which sells a distinct **"Chabad" voicing system** (Torah, Haftarah, High Holidays, Esther) with **sheet music for every melody** and a free demo. That is the single most important source for this project.
- The best freely available **notated** Eastern Ashkenazi Torah chart is a 5-page sheet-music PDF by Stephen Schmidt (Agudath Achim Synagogue, Altoona PA — a Conservative shul, **not** Chabad-labelled). I transcribed every note of it programmatically and by eye (see §4). It matches the published academic analysis of Eastern Ashkenazi Torah trope (Malin 2016, after Kalib 2002 and Portnoy & Wolff 2000) at every structural checkpoint — so it is a solid *working model* for the Chabad melody, which belongs to the same Eastern Ashkenazi (Polish-Lithuanian) family. **But it must be validated against Chabad recordings (Rabbi Michoel Slavin) before being treated as canonical Chabad** — the two are not proven identical.
- The authoritative Chabad recordings are: **Rabbi Michoel Slavin** (baal korei of 770, the Rebbe's minyan) on Chabad.org — all 54 portions + haftarot, in the interactive Torah Trainer; and **Rabbi Mordechai Schusterman** (read in the Rebbe's presence at 770) via Beverly Hills Chabad's online Tikkun.

## 1. How the system works in general

- The Torah scroll has no vowels or cantillation marks. The printed Chumash/Tikkun adds *ta'amei hamikra* (trop): one mark per word, at its stressed syllable. Each mark names a short **melodic phrase (motif)** and a **syntactic function** (punctuation). The marks are the same in every Jewish community; the melodies differ by community.
- Marks split into **disjunctives** (dividers, 4 levels: "emperors" sof pasuk/etnachta; "kings" zakef/segol/tipcha; "dukes" revia/pashta/tevir; "counts" pazer/geresh/telisha) and **conjunctives/servants** (munach, merkha, mahpach, kadma, darga, telisha ketana, yerach ben yomo), which lead into the following disjunctive.
- A verse is parsed by **recursive dichotomy**: sof pasuk ends it, etnachta halves it, then zakef/tipcha, then revia/pashta/tevir, etc. The melody is built by **chaining phrases**: each phrase = optional conjunctives + a disjunctive, and the phrase ending (the disjunctive's motif) is what the ear recognises. Motifs are **not fixed per mark in isolation** — e.g. tipcha is sung differently before etnachta vs. before sof pasuk vs. at the end of a reading (sof k'ria), and merkha/munach change shape depending on which disjunctive follows. Any synthesis engine must model **phrases**, not single marks.
- The Torah mode (ordinary Shabbat/weekday/festival) is one of six Ashkenazi modes (Torah, High Holiday Torah, Haftarah, Esther, Lamentations, festive Megillot). It is in a **major scale**, with the final (tonic) as the resting pitch, a recurrent resting point on scale-degree **2**, and characteristic cadences: sof pasuk ends 3–1, katon ends 3–2, revia descends 3→6, end-of-reading cadences on the relative minor (vi).
- There is **no fixed meter or beat**; trop is chanted freely. Rhythm is not part of the notation (the Schmidt chart says so explicitly: "Trope are chanted freely, not according to the note rhythms shown here").
- Historical frame (Chabad.org, "Who Made Up the Way We Sing the Torah?", Rabbi Baruch S. Davidson): the cantillation marks in current use date to the 9th–10th c. Masoretes of Tiberias; Chabad tradition holds the *tune itself* was taught to Moses with the vowels. The Rebbe's sichos treat the ta'amim as carrying meaning beyond conscious perception; no sicha giving note-by-note melodies was found.

Sources: Chabad.org, https://link.chabad.org/library/article_cdo/aid/817346/jewish/Who-Made-Up-the-Way-We-Sing-the-Torah.htm · Wikipedia, "Hebrew cantillation", https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hebrew_cantillation · Malin 2016, https://jewish-music.huji.ac.il/en/yuval/22542

## 2. How Chabad differs from other traditions

**Chabad vs. Lithuanian/Yeshivish ("Polish-Lithuanian"):** SMALL — same family, motif-level variants. Chabad arose in Liozna/Liadi (White Russia), inside the Lithuanian geographic area, and its leining is an Eastern Ashkenazi melody. No published source I found enumerates specific melodic differences between Chabad and Lithuanian trop. Evidence that a distinction is recognised at all: TropeTrainer lists "Chabad" as a **separate voicing system** from "Common Melody", "Spiro", "J. Jacobson" and "Wolff/Portnoy" (32 Torah systems total). Malin: "There is no single authoritative source for the melodies of Jewish cantillation, even within the Eastern Ashkenazi tradition" — variation between individual readers is normal. Two Chabad-specific details surfaced in the Chabad.org forum (see §5): the Chabad **shalshelet is "basically 2 pazers"**, and R' Slavin's **etnachta is nearly monotone**, where older sheet music gives it two notes — i.e. even within Chabad, the flagship reader diverges from the printed norm.

**Chabad vs. other Ashkenazi systems (e.g. Avery/Binder Reform, Western/German):** MODERATE — same grammar and mark inventory, audibly different tunes. Documented example: sof pasuk ends 3–1 in Kalib's version but 1–5 in Portnoy & Wolff's. The Western Ashkenazi melodies are a separate branch (Reuchlin notated the German melody in 1518).

**Chabad vs. Sephardi:** LARGE — a different musical system. The Jerusalem-Sephardic/Syrian/Egyptian/Baghdadi family reads Torah (almost) always in **Maqam Sigah**; conjunctives are rendered as flourishes leading into the following disjunctive rather than as motifs in their own right; different disjunctives often share motifs. Yemenite cantillation has only **eight** motifs total (conjunctives mostly monotone). Names also differ: Sephardim use *qadma* for what Ashkenazim call *pashta*, and *azla* for *qadma*. No special High Holiday Torah tune exists in any Sephardic tradition.

**Chabad vs. Chabad-adjacent:** TropeTrainer also lists a Chabad system for High Holidays and Esther — so the Chabad variants extend beyond Torah, but Torah is the only scope here.

## 3. The Torah mode in numbers (Eastern Ashkenazi, cross-checked)

Tonic = C in the Schmidt chart (C major, no sharps/flats except one marked B♭ in the segol melisma). Scale degrees below are relative to C (1=C5, 2=D5, 3=E5, 4=F5, 5=G5, 6=A5, 7=B5; below the tonic 7=B4, 6=A4, 5=G4, 4=F4). Range of the whole chart: F4–A5. Reciting tones are 1 (C5) and 2 (D5); the final is 1. (Malin's Kalib/Portnoy examples are notated in F major with one flat — same relative degrees, different absolute pitch. Absolute pitch is a free choice; readers chant at any comfortable level.)

## 4. Motif inventory

Transcribed from Stephen Schmidt, "Torah Trope" (5 pp., treble clef, C major), https://www.agudatachim.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/05/torahsheet.pdf — every notehead measured programmatically from the PDF (staff-line geometry → diatonic pitch) and verified visually staff by staff, including beams, rests, the B♭/♮ signs in the segol staff, and the open-headed half-note final of sof k'ria. Cross-checks against Malin 2016 are noted per row.

Confidence key: **A** = notated in the chart and corroborated by Malin/Kalib/Portnoy · **B** = notated in the chart only · **C** = known only from recordings/forum, not notated anywhere found.

| Ta'am | Motif as notated (C major; phrase context in brackets) | Degrees | Conf. |
|---|---|---|---|
| Sof pasuk (siluk) | [merkha–tipcha–merkha–] **D5 D5 E5 C5** on *sof-pa-su-uk* | 2 2 3 1 | A |
| Etnachta | [merkha–tipcha–munach–] **C5 C5 D5** on *et-nach-ta* | 1 1 2 | A (but see Slavin variation, §5) |
| Zakef katan | [mahpach–pashta–munach–] **G5 G5 E5 D5** on *ka-to-on* | 5 5 3 2 | A |
| Zakef gadol | **C5 C5 E5 G5 E5 D5** on *za-keyf ga-do-o-ol* | 1 1 3 5 3 2 | B |
| Tipcha | **D5 E5** (before etnachta / sof pasuk); **D5 G5 E5** at end of a reading (sof k'ria) | 2–3; 2–5–3 | A |
| Revia | [munach–munach–] **E5 E5 D5 C5 B4 A4** on *r-vi-i-i-i-i* | 3 3 2 1 7 6 | A |
| Tevir | **D5 C5 B4 C5 D5** on *t-vi-i-i-ir*; preceded by darga **G5 G5 F5 E5 D5** (longer phrases) or merkha **D5 D5** (shorter) | 2 1 7 1 2 | A |
| Pashta | [mahpach–] **C5 G5** on *pash-ta* | 1–5 | A |
| Yetiv | **G5 G5** on *y'-tiv*, then munach **E5 E5 D5** + katon **G5 G5 E5 D5** | 5 5 | B |
| Segol | [munach **C5 C5**, zarka **C5 C5**, melisma **B♭4 A4 G4 A4 G4 F4**, munach **F4 C5**,] **C5 D5 C5** on *se-go-ol* | 1 2 1 (melisma ♭7 6 5 6 5 4) | B |
| Zarka | **C5 C5** reciting, then the long descending melisma **B♭4–A4–G4–A4–G4–F4** (the only chromatic note in the whole chart) | 1 1, then ♭7…4 | B |
| Munach | Depends on what follows: **E5 C5** (before etnachta); **E5 E5 D5** (before katon/yetiv); **C5 C5** (before zarka/telisha/segol) | varies | A |
| Kadma | **C5 C5** (reciting on 1), shown only inside kadma-v'azla | 1 1 | B |
| Mahpach | **G5 G5 C5** on *ma-pa-ach* (before pashta) | 5 5 1 | A |
| Merkha | **B4 D5 B4** (before tipcha); **D5 D5** (before tevir; in sof k'ria); **E5 C5** (before sof pasuk) | 7–2–7; 2–2; 3–1 | A |
| Darga | **G5 G5 F5 E5 D5** on *dar-ga-a-a-ah* (elaborated run before tevir) | 5 5 4 3 2 | B |
| Telisha gedola | Recite on **C5 (×8)**, closing **E5 D5 E5** | 1… 3 2 3 | B |
| Telisha ketana | Recite on **C5 (×8)**, closing **E5 D5 C5** (differs from gedola only in the last note) | 1… 3 2 1 | B |
| Geresh | **G5 G5 D5** on *ge-e-resh* | 5 5 2 | B |
| Gershayim | **C5 D5 E5 D5 C5 D5 E5** on *ger-sha-yi-i-i-i-im* | 1 2 3 2 1 2 3 | B |
| Kadma-v'azla | Kadma **C5 C5**; azla **C5 E5 G5 E5 A5 G5** on *v-az-la-a a-ah* | 1 1 / 1 3 5 3 6 5 | B |
| Pazer | **C5 C5 D5 D5 E5 A5 G5 E5 D5** on *pa-ze-e-e-e-e-e-e-er* | 1 1 2 2 3 6 5 3 2 | B |
| Sof k'ria (end-of-reading coda) | Merkha **D5 D5**, tipcha **D5 G5 E5**, merkha **E5 C5**, **D5 E5 D5 A4** (final *ah* is a half note) | 2 2 / 2 5 3 / 3 1 / 2 3 2 6 | A |
| Shalshelet | Not in chart. Chabad.org forum: "The Chabad Shalshelet is basically 2 Pazers" (another poster: three pazerim). 4 occurrences in the Torah. | — | C |
| Karnei parah | Not in chart. Forum: "a combination of the Mercha Kefulah and Telisha Gedola." 1 occurrence in the Torah. | — | C |
| Mercha kefula | Not in chart; 1 occurrence in the Torah; linked to karnei parah (above). | — | C |
| Yerach ben yomo | Not in chart; 1 occurrence in the Torah. | — | C |
| Munach legarmeh | Not in chart as such (munach + paseq); sing the contextual munach figure. | — | C |

Notes on the table:
- The chart notates **phrases**, not isolated marks — that is the correct unit. A ta'am's realisation depends on its neighbours and on position (mid-verse vs. end of verse vs. end of reading).
- The chart lists phrase variants (e.g. etnachta 1A–1D, katon 3A–3F, telisha 9A–9D) but notates only the fullest form of each.
- Two published variants differ from the chart at one point: Portnoy & Wolff's sof pasuk ends **1–5** where Kalib (and the chart) end **3–1** (Malin, Ex. 10a vs 10b). Treat the sof-pasuk ending as a known variation point.
- The chart's home is Agudath Achim Synagogue, Altoona PA (Conservative; Dr. Stephen Schmidt, a member). It labels **no** tradition. It is used here as the Eastern Ashkenazi working model, not as a Chabad document.

## 5. Authoritative documentation & recordings

**Chabad recordings (the ground truth for Chabad):**
- Chabad.org, **Torah Reading Recordings by Rabbi Michoel Slavin** — all 54 portions + haftarot; Slavin is the regular baal korei in the central Chabad synagogue (770 Eastern Parkway) and the Rebbe's minyan: https://www.chabad.org/multimedia/audio_cdo/aid/983326/jewish/Torah-Reading-Recordings.htm
- Chabad.org, **Interactive Torah Trainer (Demo)** — word-by-word highlighting with Slavin's voice (labelled "Chabad"); also voices of R' Chayim B. Alevsky and R' Levi Kaplan: https://www.chabad.org/library/howto/trainer_cdo/aid/2747444/jewish/Interactive-Torah-Trainer-Demo.htm
- Chabad.org, **Torah Reading Trop (Ta'amim)** — Slavin's recording of the trop names themselves, with a long forum thread containing the Chabad-specific details quoted in §2/§4 (Slavin's monotone etnachta as personal style; shalshelet = 2 pazers; karnei parah = mercha kefula + telisha gedola): https://www.chabad.org/multimedia/music_cdo/aid/931078/jewish/Torah-Reading-Trop.htm
- Beverly Hills Chabad, **Learn to Read the Torah Online** — full weekly portions with audio by **Rabbi Mordechai Schusterman**, who "frequently read the Torah in the Rebbe's presence at Lubavitch World Headquarters at 770 Eastern Parkway"; includes a Taamei Hamikra learning section: https://www.beverlyhillschabad.com/torah-reading/TORAH-MENU.HTM
- ChabadInfo, weekly **"Prepare for Krias Hatorah"** posts — Slavin MP3s of parsha, haftorah and Shnayim Mikra, "published exclusively for the benefit of Shluchim and Chabad Baalei Keriah": http://chabadinfo.com/news/prepare-for-krias-hatorah-parshas-naso/ (weekly series)
- Anash.org on the Chabad.org trainer: https://anash.org/leining-megillah-just-got-that-much-easier/ ("For decades, many have used the popular recordings of R' Michoel Slavin, longtime baal korei in the main minyan in 770.")

**Chabad teaching material (audio-based, no notation):**
- Rabbi Levi Lipinski, *Bar Mitzvah Torah Trainer* (The Mitzvah Club, 2019, ISBN 978-1-7923-0466-8) — Chabad bar-mitzvah curriculum (Alter Rebbe ktav font; reviewed by Chabad shluchim). P. 23 is a symbol-only chart of all 26 ta'amim; the melodies are taught **by QR-code audio only** (SoundCloud sets): https://soundcloud.com/themitzvahclub/sets/barmitzvah-torah-trainer-torah-cantillations-taamei-hamikra — full book PDF: https://cdnm.heyzine.com/files/uploaded/v2/6c350fda191e1cd1deda45717fc2048d181aa000.pdf

**The one place a Chabad melody exists as data + sheet music:**
- **TropeTrainer** (tropetrainer.com) — web app, 79+ voicing systems; **"Chabad"** is a listed system for Torah (32 systems), High Holidays, Haftarah (25) and Esther, each with "built-in sheet music for every melody", 12 voice styles, 0.25×–2× speed, word-level highlighting. Subscription $13/month or $130/year; **free demo with no account** ("Hear Them All in the Demo"). This is the first place to check for a machine-readable Chabad melody. https://www.tropetrainer.com/ · https://www.tropetrainer.com/plans

**Scholarly / notated Eastern Ashkenazi sources (not Chabad-specific):**
- Yonatan Malin, "Eastern Ashkenazi Biblical Cantillation: An Interpretive Musical Analysis", *Yuval* 10 (2016) — full text + notation images + audio, Hebrew University Jewish Music Research Centre: https://jewish-music.huji.ac.il/en/yuval/22542 — the key analytical source: Torah mode = major scale, final = tonic, resting point on 2, sof pasuk 3–1, katon 3–2, revia 3→6, end-of-section on vi; "no single authoritative source… even within the Eastern Ashkenazi tradition."
- Joshua R. Jacobson, *Chanting the Hebrew Bible* (2nd expanded ed., 2017, 845 pp.) — ch. 6 (40% of the book) gives full notation for all six Ashkenazic systems incl. Torah; companion site with 330+ audio examples: https://www.chantingthehebrewbible.com (described in review at https://docslib.org/download/2544534/joshua-r-jacobsons-chanting-the-hebrew-bible)
- Sholom Kalib, *The Musical Tradition of the Eastern European Synagogue* (2002) — notation from Western-Ukrainian family tradition, Chicago cantors, 1970s fieldwork (cited via Malin).
- Portnoy & Wolff, *The Art of Torah Cantillation* (UAHC, 2000/2001) — the Wolff/Portnoy system (cited via Malin; also the basis of the IvritSuite Trope Tutor staffs, https://ivritsuite.com/trope_tutor.html — but note: those staffs are the **Avery/Binder Reform** melody, not Chabad).
- Stephen Schmidt, "Torah Trope" sheet music (2019), transcribed in §4: https://www.agudatachim.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/05/torahsheet.pdf
- Wikipedia, "Hebrew cantillation" (tradition taxonomy; Polish-Lithuanian "the most common tune in the world today"; Sephardi Maqam Sigah; Yemenite 8 motifs): https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hebrew_cantillation

**Other:** Idelsohn's early-20th-century field collections (historical); a German printed page of Torah-trop notation in B-flat (seen only as a social-media photo, not examined).

## 6. Verdict: text-reproducible vs. recordings-only

| Layer | Status |
|---|---|
| Grammar (which mark, phrase hierarchy, conjunctive/disjunctive rules, recursive dichotomy) | Fully documented in text (Malin, Jacobson, Wikipedia, Lehrhaus). Machine-readable rule systems exist. |
| Eastern Ashkenazi Torah mode (scale, resting pitches, cadence shapes) | Documented precisely in text + notation (Malin; Kalib; Portnoy & Wolff; Schmidt chart §4). Reproducible from text alone. |
| The **Chabad** melody specifically | **Not documented in staff notation in any public source found.** Exists as: (a) a named voicing system inside TropeTrainer (with sheet music behind a subscription/demo); (b) recordings by Slavin and Schusterman. Reproducing it faithfully requires either licensing/reading the TropeTrainer Chabad data or **transcribing Slavin's recordings by ear** (or by pitch analysis) and diffing against the §4 chart. |
| Rare marks (shalshelet, karnei parah, mercha kefula, yerach ben yomo) | Recordings/forum only. Shalshelet (Chabad) = 2 pazers is the only Chabad-specific statement found. |
| Intra-Chabad variation | Real and documented: Slavin's near-monotone etnachta vs. the two-note etnachta of older sheet music. Any tool must pick a reference reader and say so. |

## 7. Recommended path for the engineer

1. Open the **TropeTrainer free demo**, select the **Chabad** voicing system, and inspect its sheet music for the trop phrases. If the demo exposes the Chabad system's note data, that becomes the canonical motif table — it is the only source that claims to *be* the Chabad melody in notated form.
2. In parallel, take the §4 chart as the **working hypothesis** (it is the best freely available notation and matches Malin/Kalib at every checkpoint).
3. Validate the hypothesis against **Slavin's Chabad.org recordings**: transcribe by ear/pitch-tracking the first verses of Bereishit (which contain merkha-tipcha-munach-etnachta, katon, sof pasuk) and diff against §4. Pay special attention to: etnachta (Slavin reportedly flattens it), the sof-pasuk ending (3–1 vs 1–5), and the shalshelet (2 pazers?).
4. Model **phrases, not marks**: phrase = [conjunctives…] + disjunctive; the disjunctive's motif is the phrase ending; conjunctives (munach/merkha/mahpach/kadma/darga) vary with the following disjunctive. Include the **sof k'ria coda** (end of each aliyah/reading) as a distinct phrase ending on vi.
5. Do not use Avery/Binder (Reform) or Wolff/Portnoy charts as the Chabad melody — they are different voicing systems for the same marks. Do not use Sephardi sources at all for this tool.
6. Text source for the words + ta'amim: any Chumash/Tikkun text with cantillation marks (Unicode U+0591–U+05AF). The melody is a function of (ta'am sequence, phrase position) — not of the words.

## 8. Caveats

- The §4 transcription is mine, from a document that does not label its tradition; it is presented as an Eastern Ashkenazi working model, not as "the Chabad melody". Every note was measured and visually verified, but a second pair of ears (or a pitch-tracker run over Slavin) is still owed before calling it Chabad.
- "Chabad trop" as a *named, distinct* system is attested mainly by TropeTrainer's voicing list and by community usage; no book or article found defines how it differs, note by note, from the generic Polish-Lithuanian melody. The honest size of the difference is "small, motif-level variants within one family" — with the shalshelet and Slavin's etnachta as the only concrete differences found.
- Pronunciation: Chabad uses Ashkenazi pronunciation (e.g. *t*av, *s*av). TropeTrainer offers the Chabad system in Ashkenazi pronunciation; the Chabad.org trainer is Ashkenazi. A TTS/voice must use Ashkenazi, not Israeli/Sephardi, vowels.
